Never ascribe to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity, incompetence or greed.

Hanlon’s Razor*

 

I’ve been thinking a lot about technology recently and that was before we discovered that Jensen Huang had a zipper problem. Technology is supposed to make our lives easier, make us more productive. The promise of the personal computer age was that with everyone equipped with modern technology, our lives would become easier to manage. I’m old enough to remember the ads about how we would organize our recipes, balance our checkbooks and automate our homes in the “paperless” office. What we got instead, for about the first two decades of the PC, was a revved up typewriter. You could indeed put your recipes in your PC where you could ignore them just like you did the ones you cut out of the newspaper. You could also balance your checkbook – or ignore it until tax time like you did before PC. It turns out that a spreadsheet to balance your checkbook was a tad overkill and a simple calculator was sufficient to the task. As for paperless, we discovered, once again, that if you make something cheaper to do, such as make documents, people will do more of it; the PC increased paper usage. 

Things certainly changed when the internet came along. It took a while but now I can save my recipes on magazine websites like the New York Times, where I have 84 saved of which I’ve made…5.  I have 36 more saved in Southern Living and most of them I cannot fathom why; the only ones I’ve made, I did from memory (mine, not the computer’s). We can also stream endless programs on Netflix, Disney +, Paramount +, Amazon Prime, Hulu, Peacock, HBO Max, Apple TV, Tubi, Roku, YouTube and something called Crunchyroll. The programs were once neatly organized by your cable company in one long but easy to navigate guide; now you get the joy of determining which app to use (does Disney + include ESPN?) and finding the sign-in credentials in your password program (that probably isn’t up to date since you had to change it to keep a long since forgotten “friend” from using it) only to discover that Springsteen’s lament about “57 channels and nothing on” has somehow become quaint. There are thousands of series, movies, old shows, new shows and sports you didn’t even know existed until now available to stream and the odds of you finding something worthy of your time is approximately zero. 

And now we have artificial intelligence. Its promise is even greater than the computer and the internet. In fact, it is so great that it could end human civilization as we know it – or just end it. The guardians of this new galaxy of possibility are humans who are so worried about what they might produce that they’ve asked begged the government to step in and stop them from doing bad things before they do them. Jensen Huang was not one of these people. As the seller of chips that make AI do all the wonderful and not so wonderful things it does, his incentive was to sell as many as he could and, apparently, not worry too much about who was doing the buying. And by the way, he was about as well connected to the US government – and maybe some other less friendly ones too – as anyone in Silicon Valley. I don’t think the politicians get a pass on this mess. The “who knew what when” game appears to have started already. 

The Huang scandal and his resignation, in addition to making it really easy for AI to write dirty jokes, has a lot of investors wondering how it will affect the AI buildout. Rumors swirled all last week about who was doing whom and whether they might work for the Chinese or the North Koreans or the Russians. Speculation about “who set up Jensen Huang” ran rampant although my guess is that the answer is Jensen Huang. Did he know Nvidia’s chips were going to China? I don’t know and I’m sure he’d deny it, but the sound of the cash register has blinded many a businessman in the past. As for Alice Huang – the alleged Chinese spy – my guess is that she just wanted to sell her cloud computing services. Did her company – a Singapore company with data centers around Asia – sell that service to Chinese companies? Hmm. Well, Singapore sure seemed to think so. They’ve been investigating (since February 2025) whether Mrs. Huang and Megaspeed (her company) worked to get banned Nvidia AI chips to China. 

I don’t think it matters all that much which razor one uses – Occam or Hanlon – the obvious answer is likely the right one. No conspiracy theories are required for greed. Nvidia makes the most advanced AI chips on the planet and Huang wanted to sell as many of them as he possibly could. Alice Huang’s company sold cloud computing services and she wanted to sell as much of it as she could. (I should point out that Megaspeed says she left the company in August of 2025. Her current whereabouts are a matter of speculation.) As for the alleged spying by China I am shocked – shocked I say – that there’s espionage going on in here. Of course China is spying on us. So are the Russians, the North Koreans and whole bunch of countries you probably think of as friendly to the US. And we’re spying on all of them too. As for the sex scandal allegations, surely most people aren’t shocked to learn that a wealthy man had a mistress. Or two. Or three. I think it’s disgusting and stupid but it is far from uncommon. 

Nvidia is at the nexus of a lot that is going on in the AI universe, from producing the chips to financing startups to buying equity stakes in other AI companies to backstopping data centers. Other than continuing to make chips, I’d guess a lot of the other stuff is now on hold, maybe never to return. Will the companies in Nvidia’s orbit be able to find other financing? That is a concern for them but also for Nvidia if these companies can’t finance future purchases of Nvidia chips. How much of Nvidia’s business is with companies they’ve financed? Hard to say but Nvidia’s client list is pretty short; 60% of revenue last quarter came from just 4 companies. Another concern for Nvidia is that Huang basically ran the company by himself. There is no COO and Huang had 60 direct reports. He seems to be the only one who has (had) a grasp of the entire picture. The CFO, Collette Kress, has been named interim CEO but there are reports that Huang disparaged her as “a deer in the headlights” and that she was a “numbers reporter” and not someone who could “set strategy”. There are also reports that she pushed back on vendor financing, including deals led by Huang’s son-in-law. Nvidia’s management seems unlikely to get the benefit of the doubt. Next week’s earnings call should be interesting. 

Does all this matter for investors who aren’t all in on AI? It could, but so far that hasn’t been the case. The S&P 500 was up 2.5% last week while Nvidia fell 12.8%. Since Nvidia peaked the S&P 500 is down just 3.2%. Of the top 10 companies in the index, 5 are up (Lilly, Berkshire Hathaway, Apple, Amazon and Tesla) and 5 are down (Microsoft, Broadcom, Meta, Alphabet and Nvidia) since Nvidia’s peak. The index is still heavily tilted to AI and tech stocks but to really hit the index – “the market” – you’d have to see more uniform outcomes. Given how the top 10 stocks are acting right now, it seems the market doesn’t see Nvidia’s problems as fatal to the industry. The AI mania may have peaked; look at all the smaller companies that were kited based on being somehow AI adjacent. But the boom looks like it has more to run. 

If, on the other hand, AI development does slow, then we might have a problem. Much of what passes for economic growth these days is a result of the capital spending on AI. I say “passes for economic growth” because spending shows up in GDP whether it is wasted or not. Success will be seen in the productivity numbers, which are noisy and heavily revised. But nothing in them so far comes close to justifying the investment. There does appear to be some stress in credit markets when it comes to AI which might induce said slowdown. Whether that’s a bad thing or a good thing is hard to say. It could reduce NGDP and get inflation back to the 2% trend which would likely be welcomed by the market. Or it could push the economy into a recession.

And I guess that is the crux of the AI investment question. When it comes to AI, the list of unknowns is unusually long. We don’t know what AI’s capabilities will become. For that matter the vast majority of investors don’t even know what AI’s capabilities are now since we don’t have access to the newest models and probably wouldn’t know how to use them if we did. We don’t know how fast companies will adopt AI or what they will use it for or what they’ll be willing to pay for it. We don’t know which companies or sectors or industries will benefit the most from AI. If this goes like all the other tech revolutions that came before it, there will be companies that fail, probably big ones. There will probably be companies we haven’t heard of yet or companies that haven’t even been formed yet that end up the biggest winners from AI. And we have no idea if the money being borrowed to do all this will be paid back. That isn’t all the things we don’t know by a long shot but even with a small sample, the chance of anticipating the correct outcome of all of them approaches zero.

I’m not as much a Luddite as my initial little rant makes it seem. Technology has improved productivity at the corporate level. Most of what I’m complaining about above is, in a way, about exactly that. Companies, for instance, are indeed saving gobs of money using bots for customer service or what passes for it today. But the work didn’t disappear, it moved. The hold time, the menu maze, the three attempts to reach a human and the hour spent hunting for an answer on a website are still costs. They just show up on the customer’s books now instead of the company’s, and nobody measures them. It seems good to the company because it looks like customer service is cutting down on call times and getting fewer calls. It also results in a large number of frustrated and angry customers. Customer satisfaction is falling and customer complaints are at all time highs. So, yes, technology has indeed had an impact on productivity but I wonder how long it can last if the result is angry customers. The premise of capitalism is pretty simple: businesses earn profits by satisfying the wants, needs and hopes of their customers. Companies that forget that will get reminded by their income statements.

Technological change is difficult and especially for those of us who have been around a while and are set in our ways. But I have always been fascinated by what I can accomplish with technology. This weekly newsletter is a great example of how technology has improved my life. Thanks to the internet I can write this and send it out to thousands of people on Monday morning for the marginal cost of the time it took me to write it. That is a megaphone I never expected to have and I try my best to make it worth your time every week.

Joe Calhoun

 

*This phrase was submitted to a book about Murphy’s Law by a guy named Robert Hanlon, although no one seems to know who he was; I added greed because it seemed unlikely he would object. Hanlon likely got it from Robert Heinlein’s novella, Logic of Empire, in which a character cites the “devil theory” fallacy; “You have attributed conditions to villainy that simply result from stupidity”. In researching this I also came across Fred Clark’s law – “Any sufficiently advanced incompetence is indistinguishable from malice.” – but I can find nothing about who the heck Fred Clark is or was. Interestingly, the phrase is also attributed to someone named “Grey” but again I can find no information about who this Grey might be. However, the phrase is really a modification of Arthur C. Clarke’s (a real person who is well known) third law: “Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.” Which is how I figured I would connect all this to AI when I started writing this. That’s when I read the other two of Clarke’s laws, which I don’t think I ever had in the past. They seem to fit quite well with AI as well. Here are all three in order:

  1. First Law: “When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong.”
  2. Second Law: “The only way of discovering the limits of the possible is to venture a little way past them into the impossible.”
  3. Third Law: “Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.”

And now you also know why these commentaries often take me most of a day to write. Which leads me to Calhoun’s Law: “Any sufficiently deep rabbit hole is indistinguishable from research.”

**Alhambra and/or its clients and employees own NVDA stock. As of last Friday, the position was 0.15% of our Assets Under Management.